Casg 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page1of11 Page ID #:2835
—
Timothy J. Halloran - 104498 Thomas P. Mazzucco - 139758
2 |} MURPHY, PEARSON, BRADLEY & FEENEY 88 Kearny Street, 10th Floor 3 |] San Francisco, CA 94108-5530 Tel: (415) 788-1900 4 || Fax: (415) 393-8087 5 || Specially Appearing for JOHN STEELE 6 7 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 8 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 9 10 | i INGENUITY 13 LLC, Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx) Plaintiff, OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED 12 EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY V. PUTATIVE JOHN DOE 13 JOHN DOE, | | 14 Judge: Hon. Otis D. Wright, II Defendants. Courtroom: 1 15 Date: at 2, 2013 Time: 10:00 A.M. 16 Complaint Filed: September 27, 2012 17 Trial Date: None 18 , | — , John Steele (“Steele”), specially appearing, hereby objects to the following 19 purported evidence submitted by putative John Doe: 20 21
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 9 5 Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Double Hearsay. FRE 805. Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
97 || Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 48 Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. 28 _|-
OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx) PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 7 6
Cas@ 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page 2o0f11 Page ID #:2836
—
0 Oo YN DO WNW BR WwW bw
Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication.FRE 901. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 910 Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 411 Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 912 Relevance. FRE 401.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Relevance; the document speaks for itself. FRE 403 Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Relevance; the document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 914 Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 915 Relevance. FRE 401.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Relevance; the document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 916 Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 917 Relevance. FRE 401.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Double hearsay. FRE 805.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 918 Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 919 Relevance. FRE 401.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance; the document speaks for itself. FRE 403. Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication.FRE 901. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 99
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 413
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 920
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), §21
oe OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx)
PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
Case 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page 3o0f11 Page ID #:2837
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 922 Relevance. FRE 401.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Relevance; the document
speaks for itself. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 424 Relevance. FRE 401. Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 925 — 27 Relevance. FRE 401.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), (29 Lacks foundation, FRE602, | | Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 930-34 Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication.FRE 901. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation (re: reference to Cooper’s attorney). FRE 602. Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation (re: reference to Cooper’s attorney). FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401. The document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
242
OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx) PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 728
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 735
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), (36
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 937
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 938
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 39
Case 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page 4of11 Page ID #:2838
—
oO He IN Wn On FP WY WN
Relevance. FRE 401. The document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Relevance. FRE 401.
The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 743. Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 944 Relevance. FRE 401. The document speaks for itself. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 940
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 41
0 Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 945 Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Relevance. FRE 401. The document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401. The document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 948 Relevance. FRE 401. ae Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 47 Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403.
Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 78 Relevance. FRE 401. a The document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 49 Relevance. FRE 401. The document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 946
Dkt 40-1 (Pietz Decl.), 947
Relevance. FRE 401. The document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 911
_4-
OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx) PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
Cas@ 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page5of11 Page ID #:2839
—"
Relevance. FRE 401. The document speaks for itself. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
0 Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 718 Relevance. FRE 401.
11 Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Dkt 33 (Pietz Decl.), 19 Relevance. FRE 401.
12 Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 920 Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for
themselves. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
15 || Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 921 Relevance. FRE 401.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. 16 I Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 422 Relevance. FRE 401. 17 Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 59-1 (Pietz Decl.), 96 Relevance. FRE 401.
Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 912
Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 914
Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 416
Dkt 53 (Pietz Decl.), 917
So eo NY WBN AO Fe WD NY
18 The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403. 19 Lacks foundation. FRE 602. 30 Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Dkt 59-1 (Pietz Decl.), 47 Relevance. FRE 401. 71 The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403. ZZ Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Dkt 59-1 (Pietz Decl.), 48 Relevance. FRE 401. 23 The document speaks for itself. 7A FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. 25 26 || Dkt 59-1 (Pietz Decl.), 49 Relevance. FRE 401. a Lacks foundation. FRE 602. 28
“Sie
OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx) PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
Casq 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document125 Filed 04/19/13 Page6of11 Page ID #:2840
Oo CoO NY Da wan BR WC NO —
| = co
Zh 28
Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Impermissible Non-expert opinion testimony. FRE 701. Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Impermissible Non-expert opinion testimony. FRE 701. Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for
Dkt 59-1 (Pietz Decl.), 410
Dkt 59-1 (Pietz Decl.), 11
Dkt 117-1 (Pietz Decl.), (3
Dkt 117-1 (Pietz Decl.), 94
Dkt 117-1 (Pietz Decl.), 47
Dkt 117-1 (Pietz Decl.), 8
themselves. FRE 403. Pf Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Dkt 117-1 (Pietz Decl.), 95 Relevance. FRE 401. aa PIT Ce eS | Eetentoendatio FRE 602, Dkt 117-1 (Pietz Decl.), (6 Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for ef themselves. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Dkt 117-1 (Pietz Decl.), 10 Relevance. FRE 401. pf Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Dkt 40-2, Ex. A Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication. FRE 901. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Dkt 40-2, Ex. B Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication. FRE 901 Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Uncertified Public Record. FRE 1005. Dkt 40-2, Ex. C Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication.FRE 901. OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx) PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
=6-~
Case 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page 7 of11 Page ID #:2841
—
oO Se NY Dn A FSF WY WN
Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Lacks authentication.FRE 901.
Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication.FRE 901.
Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication. FRE 901. Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Lacks authentication.FRE 901. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401.
Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Double hearsay. FRE 805. Relevance. FRE 401.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication.FRE 901.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Lacks authentication.FRE 901. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Uncertified Public Record. FRE 1005.
OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTEDBY —~S«Cast@ Nv: CV-12-8333- OD TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY
PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
Relevance objection sustained when introduced as Exhibit 3 at March ll, 2013 OSC Hearing. Dkt 108-5.
Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx)
Cas@ 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page 8o0f11 Page ID #:2842
Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
1 |] Dkt 40-2, Ex. O 2 Lacks authentication.FRE 901. 3 Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Uncertified Public Record. FRE 4 1005. Dkt53-1,Ex.P Relevance. FRE401. || > 1] Dkt 53-1, Ex. Q Relevance. FRE 401. 6 Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). 7 |j Dkt 53-1, Ex. R Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. pf 8 peas @ ies ——Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Dkt 53-1, Ex. S Relevance. FRE 401. Relevance ? Lacks foundation. FRE 602. objection 10 Hearsay. FRE 801(c). sustained Double hearsay. FRE 805 when 11 Uncertified Public Record. FRE | introduced 1005. as Exhibit 12 4 at March 11, 2013 ' OSC 14 Hearing. Dkt 108-5. 15 || Dkt 53-1, Ex. T Relevance. FRE 401. Relevance Lacks foundation. FRE 602. objection 16 Hearsay. FRE 801(c). sustained 17 Double hearsay. FRE 805 when Lacks authentication. FRE 901 ‘| introduced 18 Uncertified Public Record. FRE | as Exhibit 1005. 5 at March 19 11, 2013 OSC 20 Hearing. >] Dkt 108-5. Dkt 53-1, Ex. U Relevance. FRE 401. 2 Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). 22 Lacks authentication. FRE 901. Dkt 53-1, Ex. V Relevance. FRE 401. 24 Lacks foundation. FRE 602. 5 Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Lacks authentication. FRE 901 26 Uncertified Public Record. FRE 1005. a7 28 oe OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx)
PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
Cas@ 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page9of11 Page ID #:2843
Oo CoO NJ Dw WA FR WH NO
met NO ke 6S
Dkt 53-1, Ex. W Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. pf Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Dkt 53-1, Ex. X Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Dkt 53-1, Ex. Y Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). ce ati
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Dkt 53-1, Ex. AA
Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Lacks authentication. FRE 901 Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Lacks authentication. FRE 901 Dkt 53-1, Ex. BB Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Lacks authentication. FRE 901 Dkt 53-1, Ex. CC Relevance. FRE 401. nee Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Dkt 53-1, Ex. DD Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Lacks authentication. FRE 901 Dkt 59-2, Ex. EE Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401. The documents speak for themselves. FRE 403. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401.
Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Lacks authentication. FRE 901 Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Dkt 59-2, Ex. FF
Dkt 59-2, Ex. GG
_9-
OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx) PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
0 Oo NY DO WN BP W NO &
— peek —_ &
24
Cas@ 2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page 10o0f11 Page ID #:2844
Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Impermissible Non-expert opinion testimony. FRE 701. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Double hearsay. FRE 805. Lacks authentication. FRE 901! Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Impermissible Non-expert opinion testimony. FRE 701. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Dkt 59-2, Ex. JJ Relevance. FRE 401. | Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Impermissible Non-expert opinion testimony. FRE 701. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Double hearsay. FRE 805. Dkt 117-2, Ex. LL Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Lacks authentication. FRE 901. Dkt 117-2, Ex. MM Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Dkt 117-2, Ex. NN Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Dkt 117-2, Ex. OO Relevance. FRE 401.
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c). Dkt 117-2, Ex. PP Dkt 117-2, Ex. QQ
Lacks authentication. FRE 901.
Relevance. FRE 401. ' Steele also joins the objection made at the March 11, 2013 OSC Hearing, to all of the improper
Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
testimony of counsel, Morgan Pietz, made in relation to this Exhibit (Exhibit 9 as introduced to the
Court).
Dkt 59-2, Ex. HH
Dkt 59-2, Ex. I
Lacks authentication. FRE 901. Relevance. FRE 401. Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Lacks authentication. FRE 901.
-10- OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx)
PUTATIVE JOHN DOE
Cas@,2:12-cv-08333-ODW-JC Document 125 Filed 04/19/13 Page 11of11 Page ID #:2845
Oo FH AN DB AW BS WO NO —
ee Wo BPO — ©
Exhibit 10 presented at March 11, | Relevance. FRE 401. 2013 OSC Hearing (Declaration of | Lacks foundation. FRE 602. Michael Stone) Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Lacks authentication. FRE 901.
Exhibit 11 presented at March 11, | Relevance. FRE 401.
2013 OSC Hearing (Declaration of Mr. | Lacks foundation. FRE 602.
Teitelbaum) Hearsay. FRE 801(c).
Lacks authentication. FRE 901. Exhibit 12 presented at March 11, | Relevance. FRE 401. a 2013 OSC Hearing (Affidavit of Steele) |
Dated: April 19, 2013
MURPHY, PEARSON, BRADLEY & FEENEY
By /s/ Timothy J. Halloran Timothy J. Halloran
Attorneys for JOHN STEELE he ee a ee ee ee ee OBJECTIONS TO PROFFERED EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY Case No.: CV-12-8333- ODW(JCx)
PUTATIVE JOHN DOE